Home > Deadman Wonderland, Episode Reviews > Deadman Wonderland Episode 6 – Evil for Evil’s Sake

Deadman Wonderland Episode 6 – Evil for Evil’s Sake

Well, all good things must come to an end. Finally I’ve come to an episode of Deadman Wonderland that didn’t impress me. Not that it’s ruined the show and I’ll stop writing writing reviews over it. But this episode commits several errors—some technical, but mostly narrative—which I find rather annoying.

On the surface, episode six seems to follow the same pattern as last time: introduce a character, put said character in the ring against Ganta, have Ganta defeat said person in an honorable/worthy foe manner, which by the logic of defeat means friendship means Ganta has a new ally for the future, and life goes on. As I mentioned last time, it’s a staple of shounen action series, and that Deadman Wonderland amps up the violence inherent in the formula doesn’t mean it isn’t recognizable.

This episode, however, finally shows the inherent conflict between Deadman Wonderland’s shounen plot and its darker, more mature themes. It also shows that “darker” and “more mature” don’t always mean the same thing either.

Meet Minatsuki. Even if the lead picture didn't give it away, the fact this show is what it is should tell you the innocent act she puts on is a complete fabrication

Ganta’s opponent this time is Minatsuki Takumi, aka Hummingbird. A girl about the same age as Ganta, she introduces herself to him as pure, innocent, and overwhelmed by being a Branches of Sin user trapped in G-Block. Of course, it’s all an act, and once in the ring she drops the facade and reveals she’s really a sadistic killer whose previous behavior was just to sneak in some pre-fight injuries.

As observant readers might have figured out from her last name, she’s also You’s sister, and the reason You came to Deadman Wonderland in the first place. You was always convinced that he had committed the murder that Minatsuki was convicted of—an impression she deliberately engineered—and has been working to get enough cast points to buy his sister’s freedom.

You does follow through on his plan to use Shiro's distraction to get into G-Block. This lets him arrive just into to interfere with the Minatsuki/Ganta match

I do appreciate that on seeing that Minatsuki is a Branches of Sin user, You manages to figure out that his sister might be less of an admirable person than he thought. Still, he insists on going to bat for her even with the knowledge she murdered their father, just as Ganta defends You in turn when Minatsuki outs You’s thieving tendencies and Ganta realizes who stole his antidote.

This concept of loyalty is alien to Minatsuki, whose mother abandoned her during the disaster that flattened Tokyo (and died all the same). Ever since then, she’s spent her life trying to betray other people before they could betray her, a concept she took to the extreme of killing her father and trying to set up You for the murder. (Why not have them both die by “accident”? It’s implied she wanted the joy of messing with her brother’s head.)

It's a perverse idea, but framing your father of sexual abuse so, when your brother loses it, you can frame him for the murder, is also really clever. Unfortunately for Minatsuki, Tamaki just framed her for her own crime in order to get another Branches of Sin user under his control

This is where my problem comes in. First off, even by the standards of Deadman Wonderland, Minatsuki is over the top. She talks about the pleasure she gets from seeing her victims’ hurt, betrayed faces in sexual terms and cackles like a madwoman as she prepares to flay people alive. Even with the provided tragic backstory, the extremes of her depravity don’t seem justified. It’s grimdark for grimdark’s sake.

That over the top feeling extends to her facial animations, contorting in ways that shouldn’t be possible for human beings. It extends to her voice acting, which sounds less like a real person and more like a junior actress trying to be Evil by layering on the cheese. Even Tamaki, who is the show’s version of evil incarnate, feels like he has a real personality (albeit, an entitled, sadistic, smug, thinks-he’s-untouchable personality). Minatsuki feels like a cardboard cutout.

For that matter, having Minatsuki's mother leave her daughter and try to rescue a plant is pretty over the top in itself

This leads to the other problem: Minatsuki, as anyone familiar with the plot outline will know, is going to become an ally of Ganta and a “good guy.” That may not happen overnight, but it will happen. And given her intensely negative response to the loyalty and goodness shown by both Ganta and her brother, the only way it will happen is by author fiat. If we take Minatsuki seriously as a character, and accept that her past trauma made her who she is, Ganta shouldn’t be able to undo that. Minatsuki’s response to a childhood betrayal was to try to wipe out the remaining members of her family. That’s a degree of psychosis you can’t just kiss and make better.

What impressed me with how the show handled Senji is how it preserved the dark, gritty atmosphere of Deadman Wonderland while keeping the essential elements of a shounen action show intact. Senji was and is an honorable, if ruthless, opponent. Minatsuki’s introduction went so far down the dark and gritty path that I don’t see how the writers will pull her out without doing violence to her character. Then again, I also think it went so far down that path such that she doesn’t have much character to speak of.

I do like how Ganta defiantly flips the bird at the spectators when they demand he give them the blood sport they crave. He'll defeat his opponents, but he won't kill them, both out of principle and out of spite

Next time, though, it looks like the focus will shift back to Shiro, who is now under the watch of the warden. Unfortunately, nearly all the scenes with the warden were blackened for reasons I have yet to figure out, but it looks like he is moving against Tamaki behind the scenes, and Shiro is a big part of that. And I’m still eager to see how those machinations play out, as I am to learn about Shiro and Ganta’s past history.

I’ll admit that I’m not eager to see Minatsuki appear once again on screen, as I know she will. I suppose my hope (if I am allowed to have one) is that with her introduction, Deadman Wonderland just won’t be able to top that degree of craziness and won’t try. If the show makes the habit of introducing sick bastards who are magically redeemed by our hero’s honorable lectures—that is, if it starts straying into Index territory—then I really will rethink my coverage of this series.

The warden's guards retrieve Shiro after she loses consciousness and return her to him. And now I'm suddenly paying more attention to the fact that they, like Shiro, are albinos

You can watch the episode here.

  1. No comments yet.
  1. September 27, 2011 at 9:42 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: